The Real Reason the Fed is Buying Treasuries Again

SUMMARY

Joe Brown analyzes the Federal Reserve's evolving approach to its balance sheet, highlighting a recent increase in Treasury purchases despite a declining share of overall national debt holdings. The discussion centers on the Fed's potential motivations, the implications for interest rates, and the likelihood of future quantitative easing measures.

MAIN POINTS

• The Federal Reserve has been reducing its holdings of mortgage-backed securities while increasing its purchases of US Treasuries since late last year. [1:00]
• Despite the Fed's balance sheet growth, its share of total US national debt has declined to around 11-12%, down from a peak of 19% in December 2021. [4:01]
• A Federal Reserve paper outlines a 'trilemma' in balance sheet management, forcing a choice between a small balance sheet, low short-term rate volatility, and limited market intervention. [7:01]
• Fed officials, including Christopher Waller, have advocated for a maturity-matching strategy, increasing the proportion of short-term T-bills in the Fed's holdings to better reflect the market. [9:00]
• Future Fed actions may include continued Treasury purchases, especially at the short end, and possible bank deregulation to absorb long-term Treasuries, supporting both balance sheet growth and interest rate stability. [11:00]

DETAILED ANALYSIS

The Federal Reserve currently holds a smaller proportion of the national debt than it did five or ten years ago, even as its balance sheet has expanded significantly since the financial crisis. This apparent contradiction is explained by the rapid increase in total US Treasury debt, which now stands at $39 trillion. While the Fed's balance sheet has grown, especially during rounds of quantitative easing (QE) and recent increases in Treasury purchases, its share of outstanding Treasuries has declined from a peak of 19% in December 2021 to about 11-12% today.

This shift is partly due to the Fed's ongoing reduction of mortgage-backed securities, with proceeds redirected into new Treasury purchases, and partly due to the unrelenting rise in government borrowing.

A critical issue emerging from this trend is the composition of the Fed's Treasury holdings. Historically, the Fed has held a larger share of long-term Treasuries relative to short-term bills, which can distort the yield curve by suppressing long-term rates and elevating short-term yields. Recent speeches and research from Federal Reserve officials, such as Christopher Waller, have proposed a 'maturity-matching' strategy.

This approach would align the Fed's portfolio more closely with the maturity distribution of outstanding government debt, potentially increasing the share of short-term T-bills to around 20% of its holdings. Such a move aims to minimize the Fed's influence on specific segments of the yield curve and maintain market stability.

The Federal Reserve faces a policy trilemma: it cannot simultaneously maintain a small balance sheet, low volatility in short-term interest rates, and limited market intervention. The likely path forward involves continued growth of the Fed's balance sheet, particularly through purchases of short-term Treasuries, to keep its share of national debt stable and its market impact neutral. Selling long-term Treasuries is considered unlikely due to the risk of pushing up long-term rates and the lack of willing buyers, unless accompanied by bank deregulation to encourage commercial banks to absorb these assets.

Ultimately, the analysis suggests that further balance sheet expansion and a shift in Treasury maturity composition are probable, setting the stage for renewed QE when economic or market pressures demand it.

LINKS

• Subscribe to the Letters From a Heretic newsletter.
• Access the free Portfolio Stress Test tool.
• List of recommended affiliate partners.
• Recommended books on finance and investing.

KEYWORDS