Snap’s “Crucible Moment” Flops On Wall Street

SUMMARY

Ed Elson hosts a discussion with Mark Gurman, Mark Zandi, and Vasant Dhar on Snap's disappointing AR Specs launch, the Federal Reserve's latest interest rate decision, and the evolving role of AI in investing. The episode explores Snap's strategic risks, central bank policy tensions, and the technological advances enabling AI-driven investment strategies.

MAIN POINTS

• Snap launches its new AR Specs, but the product is widely criticized for its design and high price. [1:02]
• Mark Gurman discusses the challenges facing AR hardware and Snap's significant investment in the category. [5:00]
• The Federal Reserve, under new chair Kevin Walsh, holds rates steady with a unanimous vote, signaling a hawkish stance on inflation. [11:02]
• Vasant Dhar explains how advances in AI and machine learning are transforming both short-term and long-term investment strategies. [19:00]
• Ed Elson reflects on Snap's declining fortunes and the heavy financial toll of its AR Specs project, suggesting this could be the company's final major gamble. [26:02]

DETAILED ANALYSIS

Snap Inc. has made a high-stakes bet on its new augmented reality glasses, Snap Specs, positioning the launch as a pivotal moment for the company. CEO Evan Spiegel described this as a 'crucible moment,' but the market reaction was swift and negative, with Snap's stock dropping nearly 8% on the day of the announcement and down 40% over the past year. The Specs, priced at $2,195, are significantly more expensive than competing products like Meta's Ray-Ban display glasses, which start at $800.

Despite the advanced technology and the company's pioneering role in AR, investors are concerned about the massive costs involved and the limited consumer appeal at such a high price point. Mark Gurman of Bloomberg News notes that while the Specs demonstrate technical progress, the AR hardware category remains nascent, with most products failing to achieve mainstream adoption. Previous efforts by Microsoft, Meta, and Magic Leap have struggled, and Apple's Vision Pro has also underperformed expectations.

Gurman suggests that Snap's ongoing investment—estimated in the billions—may be unsustainable for a company of its size, especially compared to tech giants with larger capital reserves. The product's future may lie in targeting early adopters, developers, or enterprise customers rather than the mass market.

The episode transitions to the Federal Reserve's latest policy decision, the first under Chair Kevin Walsh. The Fed held interest rates steady for the fourth consecutive meeting, with a unanimous vote for the first time this year, highlighting a unified and hawkish stance on inflation. Inflation remains elevated at 4.2%, double the Fed's 2% target.

Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody's Analytics, interprets the Fed's posture as a response to persistent inflation and global uncertainties, including the ongoing conflict in Iran and its impact on oil prices. Despite political pressure from the White House to lower rates, the Fed's committee structure and economic data have compelled a cautious approach. Zandi points out that while inflation data might justify a rate hike, the broader economy is showing signs of softness, with potential risks to growth as fiscal stimulus wanes.

He predicts that the competing pressures of inflation and a weakening job market may result in no policy change for the remainder of the year.

The discussion then turns to artificial intelligence in investing, featuring Vasant Dhar, a professor at NYU Stern and founder of SCT Capital Management. Dhar recounts the evolution of machine learning on Wall Street, initially limited to high-frequency and short-term trading due to the abundance of data. Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) and general-purpose AI have enabled the simulation of complex, long-term investment strategies, such as those used by renowned valuation expert Aswath Damodaran.

Dhar's team has developed a 'Damodaran bot' capable of replicating the expert's analytical approach, though he notes that the AI still falls short in framing nuanced questions. The integration of common sense reasoning with domain expertise, made possible by LLMs, marks a significant breakthrough, allowing AI to play a more substantial role in systematic, long-term investing.

The episode concludes with a critical reflection on Snap's trajectory. Despite its early leadership in AR and innovative features within Snapchat, Snap's market capitalization has plummeted by over 90% in five years, leaving it valued below companies like Domino's Pizza and on par with The Gap. The AR Specs project alone cost an estimated $3.5 billion—over half of Snap's annual revenue—underscoring the scale of the company's risk.

Ed Elson suggests that, barring a dramatic turnaround, this latest gamble may represent Snap's final act as a major player in the tech industry.

LINKS

• Prof G Markets YouTube channel
• Prof G Markets newsletter subscription
• Order 'Notes On Being A Man' on Amazon
• Subscribe to No Mercy / No Malice
• Markets on Instagram
• Scott Galloway on Instagram
• Ed Elson on Instagram
• Ed Elson on X (Twitter)
• Ed Elson on Substack
• ODOU business software platform
• VCX by Fundrise, public ticker for private tech

KEYWORDS