Why Rate Hikes Won't Fix Inflation

SUMMARY

Joe Brown, a former stock broker and financial educator, examines the limitations of using Federal Reserve interest rate hikes to combat inflation. He argues that inflation is fundamentally driven by both money supply and production constraints, and that current policy tools often overlook the critical role of supply-side factors and government intervention.

MAIN POINTS

• The historical definition of inflation focused on money supply expansion, as seen in the aftermath of the Revolutionary War and the U.S. Constitution's monetary provisions. [1:01]
• Government policies, such as employment taxes, can artificially raise prices and distort the natural balance of supply and demand. [5:01]
• A significant increase in the money supply, such as during 2020-2021, directly boosts demand and leads to higher prices for goods and services. [12:01]
• The Federal Reserve's reliance on interest rate adjustments assumes that higher rates will reduce demand, but this approach neglects the impact on production and supply. [16:01]
• Government spending, war, and tariffs further elevate prices by restricting supply, rendering rate hikes ineffective in addressing inflation. [20:01]

DETAILED ANALYSIS

The discussion begins by tracing the evolution of the term 'inflation,' which originally referred to the expansion of a country's money supply rather than simply rising prices. This distinction is rooted in historical events such as the hyperinflation of the continental currency during the American Revolutionary War, which led the framers of the U.S. Constitution to mandate that Congress could only coin money, not print it.

Over time, the definition of inflation shifted to focus on general price increases, but the underlying relationship between money supply and prices remained central to economic thought.

Monetarism, championed by Milton Friedman, posits that inflation is always a monetary phenomenon. However, this perspective is critiqued for being incomplete, as it primarily addresses the demand side of the price equation while neglecting supply. The price of any good or service is determined by the interplay of supply and demand, with government intervention acting as a third force that can artificially alter prices.

For instance, heavy taxation on employment raises the cost of hiring, which can reduce employment levels regardless of natural market forces.

To illustrate the mechanics of supply and demand, hypothetical scenarios are presented: if the supply of cars were to triple overnight, prices would plummet as sellers flood the market, while a tripling of demand would cause prices to soar as buyers compete for limited goods. These examples underscore that both supply and demand must be considered when analyzing price movements, and that they are constantly adjusting in response to each other.

The role of money supply is further explored through the lens of recent U.S. monetary policy. The surge in money supply during 2020 and 2021, driven by direct payments to individuals and businesses, led to a sharp increase in demand for goods and services. If the money supply grows without a corresponding increase in production, inflation results as more money chases the same amount of goods.

Conversely, if both money supply and production expand proportionally, prices remain stable, akin to the effect of a stock split where the number of shares and their price adjust but total market value stays the same.

The Federal Reserve's strategy of raising interest rates is based on the assumption that higher borrowing costs will reduce demand and thus lower prices. However, this approach overlooks the fact that higher rates also increase the cost of production, discouraging investment and reducing supply. When supply contracts, prices can rise even as demand is suppressed, potentially exacerbating inflation rather than curbing it.

Additionally, as long as the money supply continues to grow, demand remains elevated, further undermining the effectiveness of rate hikes.

Government actions such as increased spending, regulatory barriers, war, and tariffs also contribute to rising prices by diverting resources away from productive uses and increasing production costs. These factors operate independently of monetary policy and can sustain or even accelerate inflation despite higher interest rates. To meaningfully reduce inflation, the analysis concludes, policymakers would need to address the growth of the money supply, reduce government intervention, and lower barriers to production—measures that are politically challenging and unlikely in the current environment.

LINKS

• Free portfolio stress test and custom investment blueprint.
• Subscribe to the Letters From a Heretic financial newsletter.
• Recommended affiliate partners for financial products and services.
• List of recommended books on finance and investing.

KEYWORDS