Why The Bond Market Is Starting To Revolt

SUMMARY

Scott Galloway and Ed Elson, joined by Financial Times columnist Katie Martin, examine the growing divergence between equity and bond markets amid record government borrowing and rising yields. The discussion explores the impact of fiscal policy, AI-driven corporate debt, central bank credibility, and geopolitical tensions on global market stability.

MAIN POINTS

• Bond yields in major economies reach multi-decade highs as government borrowing surges and efforts to lower yields fail. [5:00]
• Investors react to the perception that political leaders are unconcerned with fiscal discipline, fueling market anxiety. [10:01]
• A philosophical divide between equity and bond investors emerges, with stocks buoyed by strong earnings and bonds focused on risk. [15:03]
• European countries, including Germany, France, and the UK, face similar debt pressures, with political polarization and rising borrowing costs. [20:00]
• Germany's regional election highlights political instability but is not seen as a major financial risk for European bond markets. [29:00]
• Recent bond market turmoil is attributed more to fiscal uncertainty and central bank messaging than to inflation or oil prices. [32:00]
• Federal Reserve Chair Kevin Walsh's approach to market guidance and rate hikes becomes a focal point ahead of U.S. midterm elections. [35:01]
• The UK and Canada struggle with stagnant growth, with Brexit cited as a major factor in the UK's economic challenges. [41:00]
• AI-driven borrowing by major tech companies increases concentration risk, affecting both corporate and government bond markets. [49:00]
• Corporate bond markets are reshaped by large-scale tech borrowing, raising questions about sector concentration and credit risk. [56:02]
• Tariffs are compared to Brexit in their potential to disrupt economic growth, though the U.S. is more insulated due to its economic scale. [59:00]
• Upcoming U.S. midterm elections and potential shifts in congressional power introduce uncertainty and possible geopolitical consequences. [1:01:03]
• The likelihood of further Federal Reserve rate hikes increases as inflation remains persistent, with market stability hinging on central bank credibility. [1:04:01]
• Investor confidence in government bonds depends on clear communication and trust in policy direction, with global implications for debt markets. [1:07:00]

DETAILED ANALYSIS

Global bond markets are experiencing significant turbulence as government borrowing reaches unprecedented levels, pushing yields on government bonds in the U.S., Japan, the UK, Germany, and France to multi-decade highs. In the U.S., the 30-year Treasury yield has climbed above 5.25%, a level not seen since before the financial crisis, while the 10-year yield recently topped 4.8%. Efforts by Treasury Secretary Scott Bessant to lower long-term borrowing costs through buybacks have failed to ease yields, drawing criticism from prominent investors and highlighting the market’s skepticism toward current fiscal strategies.

A central theme is the mounting concern among bond investors over the sustainability of government debt. The U.S. national debt has surpassed $40 trillion, and many developed countries now spend more servicing debt than on defense. This trend is not isolated to the U.S.; the UK, France, and Japan face similar challenges, with political leaders reluctant to address the trade-offs between spending and taxation.

Instead, governments continue to rely on debt issuance to fund public services, infrastructure, and defense, leading investors to demand higher returns to compensate for increased risk and inflation.

The divergence between equity and bond markets is notable. Equity investors remain optimistic, buoyed by robust corporate earnings, particularly in the technology sector, and the expectation that central banks will intervene to support markets if necessary. In contrast, bond investors are more risk-averse, focused on downside protection and skeptical of political assurances regarding fiscal responsibility.

This philosophical divide is compounded by the perception that policymakers, regardless of public statements, are unwilling to enact meaningful fiscal discipline. The result is a sense of "fiscal incontinence," with mixed messages from senior officials such as Federal Reserve Chair Kevin Walsh and Treasury Secretary Bessant further unsettling markets.

In Europe, the situation mirrors that of the U.S. Germany, traditionally averse to debt-fueled spending, has begun to increase borrowing, raising its own yields. France faces political gridlock with a polarized electorate, making fiscal reform difficult.

However, the European Central Bank’s willingness to intervene provides a backstop, reducing the likelihood of a full-blown debt crisis. The UK, meanwhile, grapples with the legacy of Brexit, which has hampered trade, investment, and growth. Borrowing costs for new UK government debt have reached their highest since 1998, reflecting both domestic challenges and global market pressures.

Geopolitical events, such as the war in Iran and rising oil prices, contribute to market volatility but are not the primary drivers of recent bond market weakness. Unlike the 1970s, major economies are less dependent on imported energy, and inflation expectations remain relatively contained. Instead, the fiscal outlook and central bank policy are the dominant factors.

Kevin Walsh’s initial hands-off approach at the Federal Reserve, signaling that markets should set yields without forward guidance, led to higher yields as investors interpreted this as official acceptance of elevated borrowing costs. Subsequent efforts to reestablish dialogue with markets underscore the importance of central bank credibility and communication.

The discussion also highlights the role of AI and technology spending in reshaping financial markets. Major tech companies, including Meta, Microsoft, and Amazon, have shifted from funding AI infrastructure through free cash flow to issuing large volumes of corporate bonds. This surge in corporate borrowing competes directly with government debt for investor capital, exacerbating the strain on public bond markets.

The concentration of economic growth and market performance in a handful of AI-driven firms introduces systemic risk, as both stock indices and credit markets become increasingly dependent on the fortunes of the technology sector. Recent moves by AI firms like Anthropic and OpenAI to seek investment-grade credit ratings further illustrate the growing intersection of technology and finance.

Tariffs and protectionist policies are compared to Brexit in their potential to disrupt economic growth. While the U.S. is more insulated due to its large, self-sufficient economy and energy resources, the imposition of tariffs can still introduce inefficiencies and uncertainty. The loss of tariff revenue has also been cited as a factor contributing to higher government borrowing costs.

Looking ahead, the outcome of the U.S. midterm elections and the Federal Reserve’s policy decisions are seen as critical variables. A shift in congressional power could alter fiscal and regulatory priorities, while the Fed’s response to persistent inflation will influence both market confidence and economic stability. The likelihood of further rate hikes has increased, with market expectations now pricing in multiple increases before year-end.

The credibility and predictability of central bank actions are paramount; any perceived missteps or lack of clear communication could further destabilize bond markets and spill over into equities.

Ultimately, the analysis underscores the interconnectedness of fiscal policy, corporate borrowing, central bank strategy, and geopolitical developments. The current environment is characterized by high debt, political reluctance to address structural deficits, and a financial system increasingly reliant on the success of a concentrated set of technology firms. While the U.S. remains the envy of the world in terms of growth and innovation, the sustainability of this model is contingent on continued economic expansion and effective policy management.

Should growth falter or confidence in fiscal and monetary authorities erode, the consequences for global markets could be severe.

LINKS

• Subscribe to the Prof G Markets newsletter.
• Order Notes On Being A Man.
• Scott Galloway's Instagram profile.
• Ed Elson's Instagram profile.
• Ed Elson's X (Twitter) account.
• Ed Elson's Substack newsletter.
• Prof G Markets on Spotify.
• Prof G Markets on TikTok.
• Prof G Media homepage.
• Gusto payroll and HR software offer.
• Quince apparel and home essentials offer.
• Vanguard bond funds information for financial advisers.
• Vanta security and compliance automation platform.
• VCX by Fundrise, public ticker for private tech investing.

KEYWORDS